I know what you mean, we have found some huge shad in some crappie lately and we are only using 1 1/2" jigs. My buddy wondering if we shouldnt upsize our baits. Though this time of the year the shad are for the most part large, we have one spot that was so thick with shad a couple weeks ago they were running into our lines and we snag some thinking it was crappie biting and some where in the 7 to 8" range. I wish I could have found this size shad in flathead season.