I would pick # 2 they have been making a difference the last few trips,i used one jar in two trips till i got my bait pump that thing makes it awful easy to use nibbles if you dont have one and use nibbles at all i would suggest one it gets old rebaiting with every fish but the bait pump takes that hassle away and it is a quality product i dont see any way of ever tearing it up.Now is the time if you are interested in a bait pump slab hunter has a special deal for crappie.com members right now,myself and 3 of my fishin buddies have taken advantage of it check out the classifieds for more info.