4 lb.'er

[Sandman]

Have any of you guys seen the "4 lb.er" on the California board??? That kid only catches 2# fish and above!!!

[wrwest]

Yes, I have seen the picture. It look like a 2 + lbs. to me too. I saw the pic for the first time last month. I didn’t leave a comment on his post. He has another post, on 4-6-06 Black Butte.

[pstone]

No way that thing weighs 4 pounds. A four pounder is 19-20 inches long! I'll give him 2.5 maybe.

[dmbutler47]

I just looked, that is not a 4lb fish. I need the scale that guy uses!!! What a joke! If that is a 4lber we are pulling fish that big all the time here in AR.

[kayoone]

I caught a 19in crappie in 1990.It weighed 3.3lbs.I caught that fish in northeast ohio in a private lake.I couldnt believe it,i thought i had a state record but found out the ohio record at that time was something like 21 inches and over 4lbs.Now thats a huge crappie...... Its just hard to believe that fish is 4lbs??

[dmbutler47]

That fish did not even look like it was holding eggs.

[tim]

No way that fish weighs 4lbs i have caught two four pounders and you could put a pop can in there mouths, that looks like a 2.5 that i caught last sunday.

[Uncle Bob]

Can someone post the link to this 4lb'er I cant find the calf. board . I know - Darn new guys !!! This is one of my buddys on the front page of this site . This fish was probally 4 lbs , but he didnt weigh it he said it was 18 1/2 " And can you believe he brought this fish up from a bridge thats 50-60 feet above the water and didnt lose it. thhttp://www.angelfire.com/md2/fishingmd/


Thanks

[dmbutler47]

http://www.crappie.com/gr8vb3/showthread.php?t=17374

[bentpole]

I'm with you fellows on that one,I maybe wrong,But that sure don't look 4# to me.I got one on the wall that I got several years back that was weighed on cert-scales ,It was 4lb 2oz,It sure look's alot bigger than the one in that picture.