If you are fishing waters that never get big waves GO CHEAP. If you are fishing a body of water that can go from calm slick to 3 foot seas in 20 minutes, go with the boat that will GET YOU BACK TO THE DOCK. No one ever leaves the boat ramp when the conditions are bad, we all skip it. But how many times have you been in calm conditions and they next thing you know the waves are rolling in? Of the 2 I would go with the Lund if budget is no big deal. For less money you can have F&F Boats in Arkansas build you a custom alum crappie boat that would be like no other where you live, built like a tank, will get you home. Look at Torch's boat on this forum. It's an F&F.