This is often a Chevy vs. Ford thing, i.e., what you like. I happen to use mostly Shimano reels but have reels of other brands that work well, too. Lots of people on here also like Pflueger. I have a cheapo Abu Garcia Cardinal 100U that works well when fishing with bobbers. So basically, it's pretty wide open.
I'd say you'd be better off to focus on what reel features make the most difference when crappie fishing. For me, instant anti-reverse, light weight and smooth reeling action are the primary deciding factors.
Good luck.