When I have to put a screw in and can't through bolt, I use a drill that is the same diameter as the shank of the screw, this isn't the threads part, this is the solid part. I drill a bit deeper than I expect the screw to go in and use a good sealant like 3M Marine adhesive 5200.
You want the threads to cut their way in, but not break out the fiberglass. Its best also to counter sink the hole slightly after you drill the hole and before you run the screw in. Just use a bit that is about 3x the size you're using to make the pilot hole.
Quit complaining about the color, just pull up your skirt and fish! -- snagged