I actually don't like the Eagle Claws, the design of the point turns in to the shank slightly (as in the Eagle's talon). In my mind, it seems that would slightly hinder the leading edge from biting into the fish's mouth in some cases.
When I can find them, I use the Mustad. Got low the other day and bought a 50 pack of the BPS XPS, which has the right design (straight point) but I tend to believe it's an inferior product over all.
Keep saying I'm gonna get some of the Sickles from VMC next time I make an order somewhere. Odd thing is, that point turns in slightly like the Eagle Claws, but the ones I've used on jigs will flat out stick a fish. Very, very few misses using them.
Of course, all of the above is just my musings. It's all voodoo anyway, so whatever floats your boat and fits your pocket book will prolly be alright.
Wannabe...