This might work.
double check your datum settings. not sure which are listed.
most likely either NAD1927 or NAD1983 (North American Datum of year of adjustment) There are a few NAD83's, each followed by a slash and another year of adjustment to a GPS control net. NAD83/95 or some such. Don't know if your GPS unit will have the later, but most likely it does.
Choosing one the the later NAD83's will give you more accurate location of your GPS unit, but location of brush pile coordinate will depend on how the project collected and reported the data.
In either case you have to set your unit for what the project used. I will double check their website and see if they made note of a datum.
make sure you are not confusing degrees, minutes, seconds with decimal degrees or confusing decimal degrees with degrees, minutes, decimal minutes.