Well if you read through the "whats the diff between perch and white perch" post.
there is a question of the better tasting of perch vs crappie. I went a step further, and added them up yep I was totally board. I came up with a tie of 3 for perch and 3 for crappie.
If anyone is board maybe you will get something different.
anymore votes?
lets here em

Good fishing

__________________
mike (papermouth scaler)

Id have to vote for yellow perch, but not by much....

yep, I also voted perch, I luv crappie also but I leaned slightly on the perch side.
woot perch ahead by 1

__________________
mike (papermouth scaler)

my favorite fish to catch is crappie.....but perch is my favorite to eat. no hard feelings crappie

__________________
fishin isn't a sport, it's a way of life.
A motto I live by. :D
[COLOR="DarkOrchid"]go dawgs!![/COLOR]

When I go home up North I like Perch when my Mom cooks them. Down south where I live I like the Crappie.

-REDBOAT

If its summer, crappies are to soft. So I vote Y.Perch. But in the winter its almost a tie, but would lean towards Y.perch for winter If I had to pick one. But crappies are more fun to catch and easier....

yellow perch hands down

deleted

Yellow perch, when I can get them. - Roberta

__________________
"Anglers are born honest,
but they get over it." - Ed Zern

Shouldn't u all be over on Perch.com?.....he he.