Run your finders and anything else off cranking battery. Don't hook the 2 together. If one is weaker than the other it will also draw on good battery. Also you stand a good chance of running down cranking battery to the point motor won't crank. If I was in your situation I'd buy 2 batteries and be done with it, But not knowing your financial situation in this case think I would buy 1 good battery then hook troller to it and use existing battery as back up without hooking together. Kinda goes against what I would normally say about buying 2 matching batteries but sometimes finances dictate otherwise.