I've fished there a few times. I've got a lot Crappie's, but have never found any of decent size. The same goes for McBride.
If you're into Bass fishing however, there are some really nice bass in both of those lakes. I normally use the boat ramp on the North side (Sugar Bottom) and start fishing the inlet straight across.
Coralville can get very busy and overcrowded, so we sometimes ditch that and fish McBride.

Good luck, let us know how it goes.